Most exporters who ask us for help have the same story, told in slightly different words. They sent four hundred emails. A reasonable number were opened. Some people clicked the website link. Almost nobody replied. The instinct is to blame the list, so they buy a better list, send another four hundred, and get the same silence back. Almost nobody runs an export marketing audit first, because the sending is the part that feels broken.
Sometimes the list really is the problem. Often it is not. The uncomfortable possibility is that the outreach worked exactly as intended: it got a buyer in Rotterdam or Chicago or Dubai to stop for ninety seconds and look you up. And what they found in those ninety seconds did not give them a reason to write back.
That is the gap an export marketing audit is built to close. Not the sending. The looking up.
This post explains the Terra Sourcing export marketing audit in full: the five areas we score, how the 100 points are divided, what you receive, how the 15 minute call works, and where the audit genuinely cannot help you. We are publishing the scoring method rather than keeping it behind the form, because it is more useful to you as a checklist you can run yourself than as a mystery. If you run it yourself and score well, you did not need us. That is a fine outcome.
What an export marketing audit actually is
An export marketing audit is a structured review of everything an international buyer can see about your company before they decide whether to reply to you, scored against what buyers actually check rather than against general marketing best practice.
The distinction matters. If you want the research behind it, the companion post on how buyers evaluate suppliers online covers the behaviour in detail. A general website audit tells you your heading tags are inconsistent and your images are not compressed. Both may be true. Neither is why a German wholesaler closed your tab. An export marketing audit asks a narrower and more commercially useful question: if a serious buyer in your target market spent two minutes looking you up today, what would they conclude, and what would stop them?
So the audit looks at your public surface in the order a buyer encounters it. Can they find you at all. Can they work out in one screen what you make and whether it fits. Can they see that real, competent people stand behind the company. Does the story hold together across your website, your LinkedIn and your catalogue. And if they do decide to write, is it easy, and does anything useful happen next.
Five areas. Twenty points each. One hundred total.
Why the audit scores what buyers check, not what marketers like to measure
There is a quiet mismatch in how most exporters invest in marketing. Budget goes to activity that is easy to count: emails sent, posts published, directory listings bought, visitors recorded. Buyer decisions, meanwhile, hinge on things that are hard to count and easy to neglect: whether a product page answers a specification question, whether a named human being appears anywhere, whether the certification claim on the homepage matches the one in the PDF. We built the scorecard around the second list. The five pillars are the same five areas we walked through in the companion post on how buyers evaluate suppliers online, turned into something you can score out of twenty and argue about.
Two deliberate choices are worth flagging. First, equal weighting. Each pillar carries twenty points rather than a weighting we invented, because we do not have audited data showing that, say, findability matters 1.4 times as much as credibility for Indian exporters. Equal weights are honest about that. Second, the score is diagnostic, not predictive.
A score of 78 does not forecast a reply rate. It tells you which of five areas is dragging, and in what order to fix things. Anyone who sells you a marketing score that predicts revenue is selling you a number they cannot support.
The five pillars and the 100 point scorecard
| Pillar | What it answers | Points |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Findability | Can a buyer searching your category or your name actually reach you | 20 |
| 2. Product and page clarity | In one screen, can they tell what you make and whether it fits | 20 |
| 3. People and proof | Is there evidence that competent, real people run this company | 20 |
| 4. Consistency | Do the website, LinkedIn, catalogue and email tell the same story | 20 |
| 5. Contact and response readiness | Is writing to you easy, and does something useful happen next | 20 |
| Total | International buyer readiness score | 100 |
Each pillar below lists what we check and the common failure we see most often. You can score yourself as you read. Be harsh. Being generous with your own site is the single most expensive habit in export marketing.
Pillar 1: Findability, 20 points
A buyer finds you in one of four ways: they search your product category, they search your company name after seeing it somewhere, they find you on a platform or directory, or someone sends them your link. The audit checks all four, not just the first.
What we check:
- Whether your site appears at all for your main product category plus a market qualifier, in the way a buyer would phrase it rather than in the way you would
- Whether a search for your exact company name brings up your own site first, or a directory listing, an old profile, or nothing recognisable
- Whether your key product pages are indexed and reachable, and whether anything is accidentally blocked
- Whether your Google Business Profile exists and matches your current address, category and website
- Whether the terms already bringing visitors to your site, visible free of charge in Google Search Console, match the products you actually want to sell
The common failure here is not weak ranking. It is a company name search that returns a cluttered page of third party listings, half of them with an old phone number, while the exporter's own site sits below the fold. Buyers reading that page do not conclude that your search engine optimisation needs work. They conclude that you might not be the real principal.
Fixing pillar 1 is usually the cheapest work on the list, and it is almost never where exporters start.
Pillar 2: Product and page clarity, 20 points
Assume a buyer lands on your product page from a link in a cold email, on a phone, between meetings. They will give it very little time. The audit scores how much of the deciding information survives that encounter.
What we check:
- Whether the page names the product in the words a buyer uses, including the grade, variety or specification, not just a marketing label
- Whether specifications a buyer must have are on the page rather than only in a downloadable PDF: grade, packing options, unit sizes, shelf life where relevant, HS code where relevant
- Whether minimum order quantity and lead time appear anywhere, or whether every enquiry has to start by asking for them
- Whether photographs show the actual product and packing, rather than stock images that appear on four competitor sites
- Whether the page loads quickly enough on a phone that an impatient buyer stays, which you can check yourself free in Google PageSpeed Insights
- Whether a buyer can get the detail they need without filling in a form first, which is the single most useful question any export website audit can ask
The common failure is the gated specification. A company hides its full product sheet behind an enquiry form to capture leads, then wonders why enquiries are low. The buyer comparing four suppliers simply uses the three who published their specifications. The form did not capture a lead. It removed you from the comparison.
The second common failure is quieter. Everything is technically present, spread across six pages, and no single page answers the one question a buyer has. An export website audit should tell you which page a buyer would actually need, and whether it exists.
Pillar 3: People and proof, 20 points
This is the pillar most exporters score worst on, and the one most likely to be the actual reason for silence. A buyer taking a risk on an unknown Indian supplier is trying to answer one question: is there a competent human being on the other end who will still be there in four months.
What we check:
- Whether any named person appears on the website at all, with a role, a face and a way to reach them
- Whether the founder or export manager has a LinkedIn profile that a buyer can find and that looks current
- Whether company history is specific: year established, factory location, capacity, markets already served, rather than "we have been serving global clients for many years"
- Whether certifications are named precisely, with issuing body and scope, and whether the certificate itself can be seen
- Whether existing buyer relationships are evidenced in any form you are permitted to share, including an anonymised reference, a shipment record or a named market
- Whether anything on the page is unverifiable puffery that an experienced buyer will quietly discount
The common failure is a company that is genuinely credible and shows none of it. A twenty year old family manufacturer with three export markets and a real quality system presents itself as an anonymous logo above a paragraph about commitment to excellence. Meanwhile a two month old trading desk with a stock photo looks identical. When the honest supplier and the risky one present the same way, the buyer cannot tell them apart, so they treat both as risky.
Fixing this pillar does not require spending money. It requires deciding to be specific in public.
Pillar 4: Consistency, 20 points
Buyers cross check. Not out of suspicion, at least not at first, but because they are assembling a picture from fragments. The audit scores whether those fragments fit.
What we check:
- Whether the company name, legal entity and address match across website, LinkedIn, catalogue and email signature
- Whether the product range is the same in all three places, or whether the website lists eight products and the catalogue twenty two
- Whether certification claims match exactly, including version and scope
- Whether the LinkedIn company page is alive, with the same positioning as the website, or dormant since 2022
- Whether the email domain is your own company domain rather than a free mailbox
- Whether the catalogue looks like it came from the same company as the website
The common failure is drift. Nobody decided to be inconsistent. The website was built in 2019, the catalogue was updated last year by a designer, LinkedIn was set up by an intern, and the newest product line only exists in the WhatsApp forwards. Each piece is fine. Together they look like three different companies, and a careful buyer notices.
One mismatch is a question. Three mismatches is a reason to pick a different supplier, and the buyer will never tell you that was why.
Pillar 5: Contact and response readiness, 20 points
The last twenty points cover the moment of highest intent, when a buyer has decided to make contact. Most of the loss here is self inflicted and quick to fix.
What we check:
- Whether a working email address is visible without a form, and whether the form itself actually delivers, which we test
- Whether a phone or WhatsApp route is listed with a country code
- Whether your time zone and working hours are stated, so a buyer knows when to expect an answer
- Whether a specific person receives enquiries, or whether everything goes to an info address nobody owns
- Whether you have a prepared first reply that answers the common opening questions, rather than composing one from scratch each time
- How long a first reply actually takes, measured where we can measure it
The common failure is the broken form. We test enquiry forms as part of every audit and we find ones that submit successfully, show a thank you message, and deliver nothing. The exporter has been paying for traffic into a dead letter box, sometimes for years.
The second common failure is response speed. A buyer who sends the same enquiry to five suppliers on a Tuesday morning has usually started a conversation with whoever answered properly first. Being the best supplier does not help if you are the fourth to reply on Friday.
How to read your score
| Band | What it means | Where to start |
|---|---|---|
| 80 to 100 | Buyer ready. Your public surface is not what is holding you back | Outreach volume, targeting and follow up. Skip the audit, read the outreach system |
| 60 to 79 | Solid with specific gaps. Usually one weak pillar is doing the damage | Fix the lowest pillar only. Do not redesign anything |
| 40 to 59 | A buyer cannot currently reach a confident yes | Pillars 3 and 5 first. They are the cheapest and move the most |
| Below 40 | Serious enquiries are unlikely regardless of how much outreach you send | Stop outreach spend for two weeks. Fix the foundation first |
That bottom row is the one we repeat on calls. Sending more email from a weak foundation does not produce more enquiries. It produces more buyers who have now looked at you and decided no, which is harder to undo than never having been seen.
What you receive
The deliverable is a short scored report, not a 40 page document. Four pages of findings nobody reads is worse than two pages someone acts on. It contains:
- Your international buyer readiness score out of 100, with the five pillar scores shown separately
- For each pillar, what we found, stated plainly, with the specific page or profile referenced
- A prioritised fix list, ordered by impact against effort, not by pillar order
- The three things to fix this week, named specifically, with the actual wording or page change where that is the fix
- What is already working, which matters more than it sounds. Exporters often rebuild the one thing that was fine
- Where the audit could not reach a conclusion, and what we would need to see to settle it
You keep the report whether or not you ever speak to us again. There is no version of it that unlocks on payment.
How the 15 minute call works
The call is optional. The report arrives either way. If you want it, here is exactly how it runs, so there are no surprises. Fifteen minutes, scheduled, on video or phone. The first two minutes confirm which markets you are actually targeting, because the audit assumptions depend on it. The next eight walk through the lowest two pillar scores and what we would do about them in what order. The last five are yours for questions.
What we will do on that call: tell you if we think the problem is somewhere other than marketing, including if we think your pricing or your product fit is the real issue. Tell you if the fix is something you can do yourself in a week, which it often is.
What we will not do: run through all five pillars line by line, because that is a different conversation and fifteen minutes cannot hold it. Pressure you toward a paid engagement on the call. If something we offer is relevant, we will say so once and send details afterwards, and you can ignore them.
You can take the report and never book the call. A meaningful share of people do, and the audit still did its job.
How this differs from an automated website audit tool
Free automated audits are everywhere, and some are useful. They are not the same thing, and it is worth being precise about why.
An automated tool crawls your site and compares it to general web best practice. It will catch a missing meta description, a slow image, a broken link. All real, all worth fixing, none of them answering the question a buyer is asking. A tool cannot tell you that your product page omits the grade that European buyers specify, that your certification scope does not cover the product you are promoting, or that your founder is invisible to a buyer doing due diligence.
Our process is AI assisted and human reviewed, and the split is worth stating. Automated steps handle the mechanical passes: indexing, speed, metadata, link integrity, consistency comparisons across your pages and profiles. A human reviews every judgement that involves buyer context: whether the specifications shown are the ones your target market cares about, whether the credibility evidence would satisfy a cautious importer, whether the positioning fits the market you named. No score goes out without a person having read the site.
That is also the honest reason there is a limit on how many we do.
The honest limits of the audit
An export marketing audit tells you what a buyer sees. That is a narrow and useful thing, and it is worth being clear about everything it does not cover.
It does not assess your pricing. If you are 18 percent above the market, a perfect website will not fix that, and we cannot see your costs.
It does not assess product market fit. We can tell whether your page communicates your product clearly. We cannot tell you whether buyers in Germany want that product this year.
It does not verify your buyers. Qualifying inbound enquiries is a separate process with its own method, covered in the post on 4 level buyer verification.
It does not predict results. The score is a diagnosis of your public surface, not a forecast. We will not tell you that fixing pillar 3 produces a given reply rate, because we have not published audited evidence for that and we are not going to invent it.
And it is a snapshot. It reflects what was visible on the day we looked. Change your site in March and the January report is partly stale.
Who should take the audit and who should skip it
| Take it if | Skip it if |
|---|---|
| You have a live website and some outreach running, and replies are low | You have no website yet. Build it first, then audit it |
| Buyers open your emails and visit your site but do not reply | You already know your problem is pricing or capacity |
| You are about to spend real money on outreach or a new site | You scored yourself above 80 honestly on the five pillars above |
| You are entering a new market and want to know how you read to it | You want a design review. This is not that |
| Someone told you your site was fine and you are not convinced | You are looking for a free report to use as leverage with your agency |
That last exclusion is not a judgement, it is a scheduling reality. Audits take human time, and we would rather give the slot to someone who intends to act on it.
How to prepare in 10 minutes
Nothing is required beyond your website address. These four things make the report sharper.
First, name your target markets, two or three specifically, not "export markets". The same page reads differently to a Dutch wholesaler and a Gulf distributor, and we score against the market you name.
Second, name your two priority products rather than your full range. A scored review of eleven product lines helps nobody.
Third, send any outreach material you are currently using: the cold email, the catalogue, the WhatsApp introduction. Pillar 4 cannot be scored properly without them, and the inconsistencies usually show up here.
Fourth, tell us one thing you suspect is wrong. Exporters are often right about this and have been talked out of it. If you think your product photos are weak, say so, and we will look harder there.
Why the number of audit slots is limited
Because a person reads every one. The mechanical checks are automated and fast. The judgement calls are not, and a scored report that nobody has read is just a tool output with our name on it.
We keep the monthly number low enough that the review stays genuinely manual. When the month is full, the waitlist is a real queue rather than a drip sequence, and we will tell you roughly where you are in it. If you would rather not wait, every check in this post is yours to run today, which is the point of publishing them.
What to do in the first week after you get the report
Three things, in this order.
Fix the broken mechanics first, in one sitting. The dead form, the wrong phone number, the missing country code, the unindexed product page. These take an afternoon and they are pure loss while they stay broken.
Then fix the lowest pillar only. Not all five. The temptation after any audit is a full rebuild, which takes three months and stalls. One pillar, two weeks, measurable.
Then resume outreach, and watch for a change in the quality of replies rather than the count. The first signal that a free export audit has paid for itself is usually not more enquiries. It is enquiries that arrive already knowing your specification, because the page finally said it.
If you want the scored version with a person's eyes on it, join the export marketing audit waitlist. If you would rather read the evidence behind the pillars first, start with how international buyers evaluate a new supplier online, then come back.
